Have I Been Thinking About Fly Color All Wrong?
Lately, I’ve been thinking about what colors my flies should be for San Luis Reservoir and O’Neill Forebay. After all these years of fly fishing, you’d think I’d have figured this out by now.
The main forage, as I see it, consists of threadfin shad, Delta smelt, freshwater shrimp, and crawdads. Shad and smelt are mostly silver, white, and translucent gray, with a little olive. Shrimp can be nearly transparent, sometimes with a pinkish tint, while crawdads tend toward olive, brown, and rust.
Yesterday, I had a great day fishing a very sparse white-and-pink fly. Nothing particularly realistic or elaborate, just a little white and pink material on a hook. And the fish loved it.
It got me wondering whether I’ve been overthinking fly color all these years. Maybe the secret isn’t matching the exact color of the baitfish, but getting the translucency, silhouette, and movement right. Perhaps a little pink against white is all it takes to suggest something alive and edible.
Or maybe the fish just don’t read the same fly-tying books I do.
After decades of trying to figure these fish out, I’m beginning to suspect they still have a few things to teach me.
Natural colors of the four forage species
1. Threadfin shad. Silver-white sides, bluish-gray or olive back, pearly white belly, and often yellowish fins and tail.

Fly colors: White, pearl, silver, light gray, pale olive, touch of yellow.
Translucent silver body, faint olive or gray back, bright silver lateral stripe, and nearly clear fins.

Fly colors: Translucent white, pearl, silver flash, pale gray, subtle olive.
Usually mottled olive, brown, rust, or dark green, sometimes with orange or reddish claws. The underside can be pale cream.

Fly colors: Olive, brown, rust, orange-brown, cream.
What I’d test next
Your sparse white-and-pink fly could be suggesting something important: translucency, silhouette, and a hint of color may matter more than an exact color match. I’d compare four otherwise identical sparse flies:
White / pearl
White / pink
Silver / olive
Tan / rust
Keep the size, retrieve, depth, and materials consistent so you’re actually testing color.








